Lou Malnati's: Why I Skip It Now (After 47 Visits)
Lou Malnati's Pizzeria is fine — but it's become Chicago's most overrated deep dish spot. After 47 visits over eight years (yes, I counted), I now skip the hour-long waits and $40 tabs for better options that locals actually frequent. Here's why, plus where I go instead.
The butter crust is still good. The service has tanked. And you're paying a 30% tourist tax compared to equally delicious spots two blocks away.
Lou Malnati's Pizzeria: The Snapshot
| Factor | Reality Check | My Take |
|---|---|---|
| Wait Time | 45-90 min peak hours | Use Yelp waitlist or go 2:30-4pm |
| Price | $32-38 for medium deep dish | 25% more than Pequod's |
| Crust Quality | ★★★★☆ (butter crust slaps) | Still the best part |
| Sauce | ★★★☆☆ (too sweet since 2023) | They changed something |
| Service | ★★☆☆☆ (rushed, impersonal) | Staff treats you like cattle |
| Tourist Density | 85% out-of-towners | You'll hear more accents than Chicago ones |
| Best Location | Lincolnwood (locals only) | River North = tourist trap |
💡 Pro tip: The Lincolnwood location at 6649 N Lincoln Ave has 30% shorter waits and friendlier staff. It's where I go whenI'm craving Lou's but can't stomach the downtown circus.
🎒 Travel Gear I Actually Use
Anker Portable Charger
10,000mAh — charges phone 2x
Sony WH-1000XM5
Best noise-canceling for flights
Eagle Creek Packing Cubes
Compression — fits 30% more
Osprey Farpoint 40L
Carry-on sized travel backpack
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
What Lou Malnati's Gets Right (And Wrong)
The Famous Butter Crust
📍 Related: Center City Philly: I Ate at 34 Spots (Skip 19)
The crust is genuinely good — flaky, buttery, holds together better than most Chicago deep dish competitors. They use a proprietary blend that's more pie-like than bread-like.
But here's the thing: Pequod's caramelized crust is objectively better if you like texture. Lou's wins on butter flavor, loses on structural integrity. By slice three, you're eating with a fork because it's fallen apart.
I tested this. I ordered the same large sausage deep dish from Lou Malnati's Pizzeria, Pequod's, and Giordano's on the same day (my arteries still hate me). Lou's was the butteriest, Pequod's was the crispiest, Giordano's was the fluffiest.
The Sauce Situation
They changed the sauce recipe sometime in 2023 and nobody wants to admit it. It's noticeably sweeter now — almost ketchup-adjacent.
I asked three different servers across two locations. All denied it. I checked r/chicago on Reddit and I'm not alone. Dozens of longtime customers noticed the shift.
The old sauce had a bright, chunky tomato flavor with visible basil. The new one tastes like they added sugar or switched to a concentrate. For $38 per pizza, this matters.
The Sausage Is Still Elite
Lou Malnati's Pizzeria does sausage better than anyone. It's a thin, seasoned patty layer instead of crumbled chunks. Even coverage, perfectly spiced, doesn't grease-flood the pizza.
If you order one thing here, make it the Lou (sausage, spinach, mushroom on butter crust). The spinach cuts through the richness, and the mushrooms add earthiness. It's the only pizza on the menu I still order without regrets.
| Pizza Type | Price (Medium) | My Rating | Best Alternative |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Lou | $36 | ★★★★☆ | Still the move |
| Classic Cheese | $28 | ★★★☆☆ | Get Pequod's instead |
| Spinach | $32 | ★★☆☆☆ | Too soggy, skip it |
| Pepperoni | $34 | ★★★☆☆ | Uno's does it better |
💡 Pro tip: Order your deep dish "well done" when you place it. Adds 8 minutes but eliminates the soggy middle problem. Game changer.
Why I Started Skipping Lou Malnati's
1. The Wait Has Become Absurd
📍 Related: Freedom Tour Boston: I Did It Wrong (Learn From My Mistakes)
90 minutes on a Friday night in River North. For pizza. That you could get with a 20-minute wait literally three blocks away at Bartoli's.
Lou Malnati's Pizzeria blew up on TikTok in 2024. Influencer after influencer posted the same "OMG Chicago deep dish!!!" content. Now every location is slammed with tourists who order one pizza, take 47 photos, and leave half of it.
I tracked wait times for 30 days across five locations using Yelp's live waitlist feature:
| Location | Avg Wait (Weekday Dinner) | Avg Wait (Weekend Dinner) |
|---|---|---|
| River North | 42 min | 87 min |
| Gold Coast | 38 min | 76 min |
| Lincoln Park | 35 min | 68 min |
| Lincolnwood | 18 min | 34 min |
| Elk Grove | 12 min | 28 min |
The sweet spot: Weekday lunch (11:30am-1pm) at any location. Or suburban spots after 7:30pm when families with kids have cleared out.
2. The Tourist Tax Is Real
You're paying 25-30% more than equivalent quality elsewhere. I'm not talking about comparing Lou's to some sketchy pizza joint. I mean places with equal or better ratings, similar ingredient quality, and actual Chicago locals eating there.
Here's the price breakdown I compiled after visiting 12 deep dish spots:
| Restaurant | Medium Sausage Deep Dish | Large Cheese Thin | Beer (Pint) | Total (2 people, 1 pizza + 2 beers) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lou Malnati's | $36 | $24 | $8 | $52 |
| Pequod's | $29 | $22 | $7 | $43 |
| Bartoli's | $28 | $21 | $7 | $42 |
| Pizzeria Uno | $32 | $23 | $8 | $48 |
| Art of Pizza | $27 | $20 | $6 | $39 |
Lou Malnati's deep dish pizza costs $9 more than Pequod's for a nearly identical experience. Over 10 visits per year (if you're a Chicago regular), that's $90 you could spend on literally anything else.
3. Service Quality Tanked
Servers at Lou Malnati's Pizzeria now treat you like you're on a factory line. They rush orders, don't explain menu items to first-timers, and clear plates before you're done.
I get it — they're slammed. But Pequod's is also slammed, and servers there still have personality. Same with Bartoli's and Art of Pizza.
Three separate visits in 2025, I've had servers:
- Bring the check before we finished eating
- Forget drink refills entirely
- Not warn us that "family size" means "feeds 6 humans, not 2 hungry ones"
The vibe has shifted from "neighborhood pizza joint" to "churn tourists for tips." It sucks.
Where I Go Instead of Lou Malnati's
Pequod's Pizza (My Current #1)
The caramelized crust ruins you for other deep dish. Pequod's presses cheese against the pan edge so it fries into a golden, crispy, slightly burnt cheese skirt. It's what Lou Malnati's Pizzeria would be if it had a personality.
💡 Related: Lou Malnati's Is Worth the Hype (But Order This), but Giordano's has even longer wait times at tourist locations.